Justice Sotomayor Told an Audience She Could Support Term Limits for Members of the Supreme Court

… appointments."

With all due respect, that's an argument about comparative politics, not about what the Constitution actually says.

Article III says judges "shall hold their Offices during good Behaviour." In other words, life tenure.

And we've been here before. When the term-limits movement targeted Congress, the Supreme Court ruled in U.S. Term Limits v. Thornton (which I worked on a tiny, tiny bit when I was a law firm associate) that the only way to impose caps is through a constitutional amendment.

The same logic applies to the Justices themselves. Any statute that would rotate sitting Justices off after 18 years, or shuffle them into some "Senior Justice" role with a stripped-down caseload, is just converting life tenure into fixed terms and hoping nobody notices. Sorry, Ms. Justice, we’ve already noticed Senator Whitehouse’s unconstitutional talk here brewing for years.

It's also worth paying attention to the timing here. This push is gaining steam at precisely the moment Democrats are poised to control both chambers of Congress, with Court expansion being discussed quite openly.

Justice Alito called this out directly in his Irving Kristol Award address, describing "a mounting campaign to change the direction of the Court's decisions by intimidating justices or, if that fails, by seriously damaging the Court's standing in the eyes of the public and then altering the Court's composition."

At the end of the day, a sitting Justice saying she'd welcome term limits doesn't make them constitutional. If anything, it's a reminder of why the difficult Article V amendment process’s indispensability matters so much and deserves to be defended to the hilt.

Finally, Justice Sotomayor knows that if some of the Senator Whitehouse-style reforms are adopted by a Dem-controlled Congress and not launched until there is a Dem President again, those who support her jurisprudential views will fill any new slots.

So she is also arguing for something to benefit herself without regard to the Constitution’s text or the doctrine of separation of powers and federalism both — since the Article V amendment process — in both of its forms — must involve the States and not Congress + the President alone.

No comments:

Post a Comment